Intellectual Property and Its Uses Part
Three: Lyric Reprint
Permissions
by Lori L. Lake |
|
|
Lyrics fall under slightly different rules than other
written materials. You can’t quote song lyrics without securing
permission. Most writers do not seem to realize this, and frequently
snippets of lyrics are included in books, stories, and novels
without the creator’s permission. This could be a very bad mistake
if the copyright owner were ever to contest the use of the lyrics
and your book was pulled and monetary damages assessed to you.
Because by
nature songs are relatively short, there is no "Fair Use" amount of
song lyrics that can be used. I read about an author who wanted to
quote from Aretha Franklin’s song, "R.E.S.P.E.C.T." but was turned
down by the music administrator, so he only used one line, "Sock it
to me." He was sued and lost, and the penalty was substantial.
(Please Note: This article refers to writers of books and stories. I
am not referring to "sampling" which is when musicians use a small
segment of someone else’s song and include it in theirs.)
There are currently only three performing rights
organizations recognized by the U.S. Copyright Office: ACSAP, BMI,
and SESAC. (I have included links to each search engine at the end
of this article.) These companies administer the rights to the use
of musicians’ music and lyrics. If you plan to use lyrics in
something you write, particularly if you mean to use them in a
thematic way, I strongly advise you to contact the
appropriate administrator and get permission in advance. Without the
permission, your entire work might have to be rewritten. An example
of this occurred when Cate Swannell, author of Heart’s
Passage, originally titled her novel King of the Beach.
In her novel, she referred to Chris Rea’s song of the same
name, and she used his lyrics as an epigraph. After Swannell was
offered a publishing contract, she attempted to obtain permission to
use the lyrics. It turned out that Chris Rea doesn’t use a music
administrator, and after many unsuccessful attempts to reach him,
Swannell gave up and had to take out the references to the song.
Without the thematic underpinnings of the "King of the Beach" song,
there was no use keeping the title the same, so she renamed the
book.
Cate Swannell did not have to rename her
book; titles (unless trademarked) are not copyrighted. But she chose
to change it in keeping with the significant difference the lack of
the song made. You can avoid similar difficulties by securing proper
permissions in advance.
To date, I have used lyrics from four musicians in
my novels. The music of Melissa Etheridge and Shawn Colvin is
administered by ASCAP and BMI respectively, and I was required to
pay a small fee for the use. The music of local artists Ann Reed and
Kristen Schuldt, on the other hand, is administered by them,
personally, and they allowed me to use their lyrics without paying a
fee because I argued that readers unfamiliar with their music would
be introduced to their songs which would benefit
them.
One more comment about music: there is a great deal
of it in the public domain, meaning that no one owns the copyright
any longer. "I Love You Truly," "A Tisket, A Tasket," "Yankee
Doodle," "Abide With Me" – all of these and thousands more old tunes
are free to use as you wish. It’s always nice to acknowledge the
composer, but it isn’t required. (I’ve included an online public
domain site at the conclusion of the article.)
So how long is copyright good? The U.S.
Copyright Office indicates that for work created on or after January
1, 1978, the rule of thumb is the author’s life plus an additional
70 years after the author’s death. For works written before 1978,
there are some complicated details, but it all boils down to no more
than 75 years. So the copyright for "Abide With Me," for instance,
which was written in 1861 with music by W.H. Monk and words by H.F.
Lytle, long ago moved into the public domain. You can use it all you
want, in part or in its entirety.
Final Comments
There is a great deal to know about copyright law, and it is
surely useful to learn as much as you can in order to protect your
own intellectual property and to make sure you don’t infringe on
someone else’s. Remember, if there’s a lawsuit about your use of
words, music, lyrics, etc., you, the writer, are responsible, not
your publisher. A publisher merely provides the packaging for
material you have certified is original. If there is a dispute, the
publisher isn’t the one on the hot seat (they just pull your book) –
it’s you, the author, who gets sued.